Insights

Are Jigsaw Puzzle Games Worth Greenlighting?

A look at 24 jigsaw puzzle games on Google Play: retention, ad-driven revenue, CPIs of $1.5 and up, and where new projects still have room.

In this article7 sections
  1. 01Category data
  2. 02IAP and ad revenue share
  3. 03Playtime and ad revenue mix
  4. 04Core fun and features
  5. 05Opportunities
  6. 06Challenges
  7. 07Summary

In an earlier article, “Greenlighting Is Life or Death, and the Target Audience Is Half of It”, we recommended that small and mid-sized teams building games for global markets start with casual. Casual is a huge category with many subgenres: puzzle, word, match-3, jigsaw, bingo, idle, coloring, dress-up, hidden-object and more. This article looks closely at jigsaw puzzle games from several angles (Google Play data only) to judge whether the category still has room for new entrants.

Category data

The analysis covers 24 jigsaw puzzle games, ranked by downloads.

The data leads to a few conclusions:

  1. The jigsaw audience is very large, and many games in the category have downloads in the tens of millions.
  2. Competition is not especially fierce: many newly launched games, once their paid UA scales up, pick up a large share of organic installs.
  3. For jigsaw games, long-term retention of roughly 7% or higher counts as acceptable, and the best competitors reach 12%+.
  4. No single leader has pulled far ahead, and some developers run several jigsaw games at once, which suggests the category keeps leaving room for newcomers.

IAP and ad revenue share

Next comes mobile game monetization for the same 24 games, in the same order, starting with IAP.

The IAP data points to these conclusions:

  1. Apart from Magic Jigsaw Puzzles, which sells paid picture packs such as Marvel and Disney sets and makes around $1k a day in IAP, in-app purchase revenue across these games is close to negligible.
  2. Some newly launched jigsaw games skip IAP entirely and have no in-app store at all.
  3. In the jigsaw category, ads are the main source of revenue and IAP barely exists, so the advice is to leave IAP features out at the start.

Playtime and ad revenue mix

Take one of these games and look at its playtime.

Going by third-party data alone, Android players already spend 2 hours in the game, and actual playtime is far higher than that. From what we have learned, it runs about 5 hours on weekdays and reaches 10 hours on weekends.

In hands-on play, a single picture takes about 20–30 minutes to complete.

These playtime figures support a few judgments about how ad revenue splits:

  1. Because players spend so long in the game, banners become the category’s main revenue source.
  2. The games offer hint items that players can use by watching a rewarded ad, so rewarded ads are the second-largest revenue source.
  3. A single round (one picture) takes a long time, so interstitials get few impressions and bring in the smallest share of revenue.

Core fun and features

We played all 24 games and boiled down their core gameplay and features.

Putting the data together with hands-on play, the conclusions are:

  1. High-quality, distinctive pictures are the core competitive edge of a jigsaw game.
  2. Small feature innovations, such as a semi-transparent overlay or a reworked hint tool, do not make a particularly big difference.
  3. Simply adding features like daily tasks does not make a particularly big difference either.

Opportunities

Several of the games stand out with distinctive features:

Game Developer Signature / core features
Jigsawscapes RelaxFun Games LLC Bright, highly saturated pictures; event and themed picture sets
Magic Jigsaw Puzzles ZiMAD Disney and Marvel picture sets
Jigsaw Puzzle Villa ZiMAD Home renovation as the main progression, puzzles as levels
Bible Game - Jigsaw Fuero Games Sp.zoo Christian-themed pictures
Jigsaw Puzzles Fuero Games Sp.zoo Jigsaw-based mini-games, stylized pictures, event and themed picture sets
Fun Jigsaw Puzzles Fun Coloring World American comic-style pictures

Taken together with the analysis so far, these games point to the following:

  1. The jigsaw category still rests on distinctive pictures, and those pictures need to be highly saturated and pleasant to look at.
  2. Innovating on the overall packaging, with the theme and the pictures working together, has some potential, as with Bible picture sets or American comic-style art.
  3. Gameplay innovation also has some potential, such as having players complete objects in Western-style pictures drawn in-house; this could later be built into a game as a signature feature.
  4. Adding other gameplay and long-term goals, such as home renovation, helps raise long-term retention and revenue.

Challenges

From the analysis so far, the jigsaw category can look well worth making. So why haven’t more developers entered it? The main reasons are these:

  1. User acquisition is expensive. Even games with innovative gameplay have a CPI of at least $1.5, and conventional ones run $2.5+, while ads are the only revenue, which puts heavy pressure on recouping costs.
  2. Mobile controls and small screens make it hard to match the ease and feel of putting together a physical jigsaw, and that turns away many players who love jigsaws.

Summary

Here is the jigsaw category at a glance:

Details
Opportunities 1. The top of the chart is not dominant; there is no clear leader.; 2. High-quality, distinctive pictures are the core competitive edge, and the bar for producing them is low.; 3. Gameplay innovation and added long-term goals (such as home renovation) have some potential.
Challenges 1. High user acquisition costs.; 2. The controls feel much worse than a physical jigsaw.
Recommendations 1. Bright, highly saturated, appealing and distinctive pictures are the core, and they must be right.; 2. Consider improving the jigsaw experience itself, which helps long-term retention.; 3. Adding long-term goals such as home renovation and collections can raise long-term retention and IAP.; 4. Put effort into pictures and ads first, and only then into growing IAP.; 5. A purely classic jigsaw is not recommended as a new project: UA costs are too high, and even with better long-term retention the payback period would be very long.; ; 6. AI image generation can play a very big role in this category, so make full use of it.; 7. Integrating more ad networks that are strong at banners can raise ad revenue a great deal.

That is our analysis of the jigsaw category, and hopefully this piece of mobile game market research helps with your own greenlight decisions.

How we review games · Report a mistake